Dec 6th, 2007
Conversations

India has one of the most eclectic mixes of people from every class, culture and religion you could imagine. Before the East India Company ran a portion of this part of the world it wasn’t one country so, put simply over 1.2 billion people have been thrown together for only the past 60 years. That’s pretty remarkable given it is now racing to be one of the largest economies in the world chasing the West and China with vigor.
I’d like to think we’ve met a pretty good mix of the people here from the poorest of the poor in Kolkata to country folk in the mountains up north, middle classes in Mumbai and Hyderabad, as well as the surprisingly well educated masses of Kerala.
The most interesting conversations for us not speaking either Tamil or Hindi (or any of the other many languages in India) are, quite clearly, with the very well spoken middle classes we meet on our train rides and restaurants. Each time we’ve seen a slightly different side to how Indian’s think of themselves.
The young professionals we met in a restaurant in Kolkata really opened our eyes to what I think of as the gap between how ‘India is’ and how ‘Indians think it is’. A young lady who works in the finance industry as an accountant rabbited on to us in a very strong Indian accent how important India is to the world and how literate all Indians are. She cites statistics which are unfortunately untrue suggesting that all literate Indians speak English and that 80% of Indians are literate. Sadly we have found in our adventures roaming this land that really very few Indies who make the day to day of the country tick speak any English at all. The challenge of explaining what you want in a restaurant or directions to a rickshaw driver is more often than not a painful challenge in itself.
So why is it that this lady was so confident that we should have no trouble communicating with Indians in India? There was even an element of anger in her tone which suggested that it was something we were doing wrong if we could not communicate.
One of the main reasons is the infamous caste system here in India which shuts out whole massive groups of society from certain professions and opportunities which we would consider just ridiculous in the West. The government is always trying to create policies to rectify this, some good some terrible. Their recent attempt is to bring into law policies that ensure the corporate sector recruit a quota of staff from lower, less well-educated castes each year. A ridiculous idea and one which will stifle the country’s growth as it takes on a whole heap of basically useless people. If they want to make a difference then expanding their education and health policies to include all and breaking down female repression would be a far better start.
People write whopping books about the craziness of India so there is no way in one little blog post I can capture the hundreds of points of view and sides to this discussion. A discussion which is happening every day in the local and international media. Many channels broadcast English-speaking news to the relatively small percentage of middle and upper classes of India and try to pull together a show to better inform. But, to be honest it’s just exacerbating the situation. The news stories are very insular with little world news getting through and the English is both hard to understand and very badly written with the over zealous use of “actually” and “ironically” (if that is a word?) at “actually” every opportunity. We got a snippet of international news one day in Mumbai: David Beckham upset a group of young Cancer suffers for not turning up to meet them. He is later seen interviewed about it and explains that he had no idea he was supposed to have seen them and would at his next opportunity. A story completely void of any interest or importance to anyone anywhere in the world. Maybe this is just a sign of international news in general?
Another conversation, on a train down the East coast, highlighted very clearly how the difference between value in India is different to that in the West. When I opened the discussion on how foreign visitors are charged 750RS (10 quid) to view the Taj Mahal and locals only 100rs, they took my observation as a challenge and spent a long time trying to argue that we should pay this relatively vast amount with no quibble. My response was to try and explain that even 10 quid in England to see a well-known building or monument like St Pauls or Lady Dianna’s memorial was a lot of money – regardless of where I’m from or how much I earn. They missed the point and started to try and equate the cost of a haircut in India to one in England. I think that there’s lack of knowledge still in India about how we perceive value and how they do. A haircut in England could be as little as 2 quid or as much 200 whereas in India, a haircut is 10rs and that’s that, no difference wherever you go. The signs to me of a young country that is growing very fast towards the world we live in back home.
A young girl of 20 we met in Kanykumari (the most southern tip of India), on holiday with her parents had just started working for a technology company in Bangalore, the techy center of India. She was writing computer programs for home-cinema flatscreen TVs. I asked her if it felt strange to be working on something which a) Is not for the people of her own country (or at least a very, very small percentage) and b) She herself is very unlikely to own. She was genuinely quite excited to have realized that this was rather odd and after I suggested she asked her boss to have a flatscreen in her home to truly understand the end product she was even more excited. I hope she hasn’t lost her job in the process :-)
It’s bizarre to think that so many of the luxuries we enjoy back home, come from a place that won’t be enjoying them. It’s simple to say this when you sit at home in front of your home cinema, feet up and glass of wine in your hand but to be here seeing it from the other side is very different. Even more bizarre that the people working on these products are unaware too. She was a lovely girl and we both wished her all the luck in the world, she will be the boss of that company one day, you can just tell.
The Indian people we have met share one thing in common, whether middle, upper, lower or whatever class. Confidence. They are so doggedly determined to succeed at either climbing the corporate ladder, convincing themselves that India is the heart of the planet or just simply ripping us off in a rickshaw. I think they’ll do it.
While China appears to grow through the direction of a few and the rest with their heads down doing what they’re told, there is an element of calculated chaos here in India with everyone scrambling to the top of the endless ladder to success.
Every state in India has its own government yet they all report to one (similar to the US system) however each state here is so different. Two of the sates have communist governments, some are almost entirely Hindu or Muslim, some are literally years behind others in health and education. So, as we have travelled around this country we might as well have been getting a new stamp in our passports each time we crossed a state line.
If you were to take your eyes off the changes happening in this country for even one week it would be like missing a decade in the history European society.